Source: Public Policy Institute of California | By Stephanie Barton
California has some of the highest energy costs in the nation, with a range of factors driving up utility bills at a faster pace than inflation. In a recent panel moderated by KQED climate reporter Laura Klivans, experts discussed the obstacles and solutions to achieving clean and affordable energy in California. “The primary driver of the increases in electricity bills is, frankly, climate change,” said Alice Reynolds, president of the California Public Utilities Commission, “having to adjust the system to make the infrastructure safer … as well as respond to the impacts of climate change, [which includes] repairs after wildfires, dealing with extreme heat” and providing the supply to meet higher and more volatile demand. Along with higher demand during the day, Siva Gunda, vice chair of the California Energy Commission, observed that demand has lengthened across summer and winter. To meet demand for “the median of the day [and] these long tails happening because of climate change” requires investing in additional capacity. Right now, two systems must be running to maintain reliability on the grid—the legacy oil and gas system alongside the new renewable system. “When you’re paying for two systems, the cost is going to be higher.” Gunda cited an expected rise in electricity use due to building, transportation, and data centers, which will further shift the point in the day when use goes up. That timing and usage “will drive the system you need to build,” Gunda said, and recommended stabilizing regulations as California phases out refineries.
The cost to increase electrification on the grid goes into the rate base customers pay—”that [base is] the biggest part of lack of affordability,” said Adria Tinnin, director of race, equity, and legislative policy at The Utility Reform Network (TURN). Wildfire mitigation and safety make up a large portion of the base rate, which Tinnin suggested might be lowered through more cost-effective approaches such as insulating conductors rather than burying wires underground.
Source: Politico | By Noah Baustin with Alex Nieves and Riley Ramirez
Mark Toney, executive director of the Utility Reform Network, said in an interview that he also opposes the idea of a shareholder liability cap, unless it’s somehow paired with a ratepayer liability cap and other risk-reducing measures. But policy details aside, there simply is not enough time left for Newsom to land the final deal, he said. “This behind the scenes, closed doors, released at the last minute, which is what we’ve done since 2019 with wildfire policy — I think that’s part of why it failed this time. People are tired of that,” Toney said. “These policies need to be put into print for weeks or months before they’re voted on.”
California’s power companies launched an all-out pressure campaign to pass a wildfire liability bill before the membership of the state Legislature changes. Now, that push seems to have fallen flat.
Source: RTO Insider | By David Krause
One challenge for implementation will be to ensure the CPUC has an approved FERC tariff in hand before it approves an entity’s participation in the new regional market, Matt Freedman, senior staff attorney for The Utility Reform Network, said during the conference. “This was a hotly debated issue in the legislature, and it cannot be ignored or de-emphasized,” he said.
Stakeholders generally agree about how the California Public Utilities Commission should implement certain requirements of Assembly Bill 825, but some are expressing reservations around how the shift in CAISO market oversight could affect resource adequacy arrangements and access to data.
Source: KNX News | By Pete Demetriou
Constance Pierre with The Utility Reform Network is concerned that the rate hike is in excess of what is needed for infrastructure and safety costs. "We are not sure that all of what they are asking for is absolutely necessary, because a good portion of that ends up in shareholders’ pockets."
As a public utilities commissioner and an administrative law judge listened, a variety of people made their case against for and against a rate hike that could pencil out to about $6 a month for Southern California Gas customers beginning in 2028.
Source: KTLA | By Chris Wolfe
Constance Slider Pierre from The Utility Reform Network says “it all adds up and what it’s adding up to right now is, more and more people feeling like they are going to be left in the dark, feeling like they are going to be cold over the winter, feeling like they are not going to have the food or medicine that they need to really take care of themselves and their families."
Southern California Gas is looking to raise rates by upwards of seven percent. Today was the first of a series of public hearings over So Cal Gas’ proposed rate increases.
Source: Broadband Breakfast | By Jake Keenan
Advocacy groups Public Knowledge and The Utility Reform Network, which had pushed California Gov. Gavin Newsom not to accept the funding, said they were still happy with the CPUC’s letter.
The Trump administration isn’t giving a lot of weight to California’s concerns about conditions tied to $1.4 billion in broadband funding. The California Public Utilities Commission said Tuesday it had accepted that money, but sent a letter to the Commerce Department saying the terms of its grant agreement were vague and didn’t override state laws.
Source: KQED | By Rachael Myron
“It’s a bad deal. And this is a deliberate effort on the part of the Trump administration to tie our hands. And out of all states in this country, California has the most to lose,” said Regina Costa, who directs telecom policy for TURN, The Utility Reform Network. “We are over a 10th of the population,” Costa said of California. “We have one of the largest economies of any nation-state in the world, let alone a U.S. State. We have charted our own course on many, many important things, and telecommunications is one of those areas, and we should not just sign that away,” she told KQED.
The California Public Utilities Commission signed the Notice of Award for the state’s $1.42 billion federal broadband grant Monday, accepting the money despite the fact that it comes with a threat to California’s consumer protection laws.
Source: The Los Angeles Times | By Melody Petersen
Mark Toney, executive director of the Utilities Reform Network, called the idea of permanently capping shareholders’ liabilities for fires “completely unacceptable.” “There needs to be a cap on ratepayers’ liability,” he said.
As a criminal investigation into Southern California Edison’s actions before last year’s deadly Eaton fire continues, the state’s for-profit utilities are lobbying for legislation that would protect their shareholders from paying for future catastrophic fires they cause.
Source: NewsData | By Linda Dailey
Mark Toney, executive director of The Utility Reform Network, called on the state’s leaders to “immediately release any draft proposal language that might be considered in a potential Special Legislative Session, so that the public may weigh in on decisions that will impact affordability for generations.” In a Nov. 3 letter to Newsom and other state leaders, Toney noted that there are persistent rumors “about a backroom deal on comprehensive wildfire reform between the utility industry and the insurance industry.”
A newly released state report evaluating California investor-owned utilities’ exposure to wildfire-related risks says that structural reforms are needed to alleviate increasing costs and liabilities and argues that failing to protect the IOUs’ creditworthiness would result in ratepayers incurring even higher rates.
Source: PBS KVIE | By Aaron Leathley
“If we’re going to have a cap on shareholder liability, I understand that … but I also want to see a cap on ratepayer liability,” Mark Toney, executive director of The Utility Reform Network, said. “So the question of course (becomes), who pays over the cap? … That is the hard question.”
Three times in two weeks, members of the Assembly’s Utilities and Energy Committee and Insurance Committee have convened executives and experts to discuss the cost of fires. The hearings mark a reopening of the topic after a deal between the Assembly, Senate and Gov. Gavin Newsom that would’ve limited utility executives’ compensation after their company’s equipment sparks a fatal wildfire fell through at the end of the legislative session about two months ago.
Source: KQED | By Katherine Monahan
Regina Costa, who directs telecom policy for TURN, lives in rural Sonoma county and says the money the federal government is offering is not worth it. “It’s a bad deal and this is a deliberate effort on the part of the Trump administration to tie our hands. Out of all states in this country, California has the most to lose."
Governor Gavin Newsom has until tomorrow to decide whether California will take $1.42 billion in federal broadband money that comes with a catch: a Trump administration’s provision attached to the funds would bar the state from enforcing many of its own consumer protection rules for about 14 years, including a ban on throttling fire fighters’ data.